Every American knows about the cyber outages cascading through systems at Microsoft, the FAA, Chase Bank, United Airlines, Apple and even the NSA, starting November 12. Some know about the hacks on European grocery stores that started in October. Many know of the “hugging face jailbreak,” of LLMs hacking other cyber programs, in July. Most are aware of the vulnerability of our public infrastructure as well as “my” private data. Many wonder, as the media cannot help but report, if the outages go beyond glitches in security upgrades, as the companies that suffered them cite.
The explanation does seem plausible – former NSA cyber official Anne Neuberger corroborates that are behind the curve raising cyber defenses. Four months after the hugging face incident, it makes intuitive sense that companies’ new patches and those would be getting installed raising glitches.
But what if artificial intelligence programs had gotten loose, as they did in July but on a wider scale? Or if a hostile party – Iran, Russia, China, North Korea, a disaffected computer nerd – was hacking our institutions?
Of course the idea of hostile hacks raises a national security issue, and obviously we must prevent major tangible damage. A quieter question, though, bears further consideration. An adversary gains perhaps more than the tangible effects if their hacking, or their AI, leads Americans to lose confidence in our institutions and operating systems. As annoying and costly as the November outages are, a loss of confidence that spreads, to our institutions and society could, in itself, portend an existential threat.
That loss of confidence could arise from AI or hacking, but can also occur entirely separately. Indeed, as Neuberger notes, AI could be the tool we need to fix current weaknesses. And columnist Alexandra Samuel worries more about harms we ourselves may already be generating, “like cognitive offloading and our tendency to abdicate human judgment …”
This nation conceived itself on premises of personal rights and consent of the governed. People, our creed implies, can viably live by their own lights and govern themselves to preserve them. If somehow we prove that free people cannot do that, this nation may be conceived in a delusion. Other nations, particularly those governed by top-down authorities, have a deep interest in proving such delusion. Discrediting America always helps the Chinese Communists, Vladimir Putin, Iran’s theocrats, and North Korea’s Kim dynasty. But beyond the everyday geopolitical sparring, a successful nation based on free people’s capacity to live freely in good social order poses at least a latent threat to any unfree regime. So, even if they don’t see beyond their day – to – day geopolitical machinations, they could gain a grand strategic windfall if Americans lose confidence in America. Whether or not our demoralization allows an adversary to prevail in some conflict against us, we need to show ourselves that free people can sustain their freedom, keeping a social order that allows it. Otherwise our very legitimacy comes into question.
If Armageddon – cyber or other – strikes, will we have the resiliency to keep to our founding spirit? Amid the lag in cyber-defenses, which we’ve known about for years, with no major bills proposed and no ‘civil defense’ drills arranged, will we only turn to blame mongering if disaster befalls us? In the wreckage, will we be able to sort out what we need from what we were accustomed to indulging ourselves with? Will we pick up the pieces of life in resentment for what’s lost, or rebuild our nation with clarity in our deepest purposes?
In a generation of rising terrorism, financial instability, social upheaval and most recently pandemic, Americans seem to have fallen into mutually alienating politicized camps, showing more interest in recrimination civic disruptions than in our founding tenets. Perhaps reflecting on what we will do if something overtly crippling were to happen, we will be willing to look beyond those squabbles.